Imagine you’re writing a note taking application.
Each note needs a unique id.
Generating unique ids is easy if you can coordinate.
The simplest way is to get database to do it: use
AUTOINCREMENT column and the database will generate unique id when you insert a new note row into a table.
What if you can’t coordinate?
For example, you want the app to also generate unique note id when offline, when it cannot talk to the database.
The requirement of non-coordinated generation of unique ids comes up often in distributed systems.
A simple solution is to generate a random id. If you give it 16 bytes of randomness, the chances of generating the same random number are non-existent.
It’s such a common problem that over 30 years ago we created a standard for this called UUID/GUID.
We can do better than GUID. A good random unique id:
- is unique; we can’t skip the basics
- can be sorted by its string representation
- is time-clustered i.e. ids generated at the same time are close to each other when sorted
- string representation can be used as part of URL without escaping
- the shorter, the better
There are few Go implementation of such id, following the same basic idea:
- use time as part of the id to achieve time-clustering
- fill rest of the id with random data
- encode as a string in a way that allows lexicographic sorting and is url-safe
Here are Go packages for generating unique id and how their ids look like in string format:
GUID libraries
| Package | Id | Format |
|---|---|---|
| github.com/segmentio/ksuid | 0pPKHjWprnVxGH7dEsAoXX2YQvU |
4 bytes of time (seconds) + 16 random bytes |
| github.com/rs/xid | b50vl5e54p1000fo3gh0 |
4 bytes of time (seconds) + 3 byte machine id + 2 byte process id + 3 bytes random |
| github.com/kjk/betterguid | -Kmdih_fs4ZZccpx2Hl1 |
8 bytes of time (milliseconds) + 9 random bytes |
| github.com/sony/sonyflake | 20f8707d6000108 |
~6 bytes of time (10 ms) + 1 byte sequence + 2 bytes machine id |
| github.com/oklog/ulid | 01BJMVNPBBZC3E36FJTGVF0C4S |
6 bytes of time (milliseconds) + 8 bytes random |
| github.com/chilts/sid | 1JADkqpWxPx-4qaWY47~FqI |
8 bytes of time (ns) + 8 random bytes |
| https://github.com/lithammer/shortuuid | dwRQAc68PhHQh4BUnrNsoS |
UUIDv4 or v5, encoded in a more compact way |
| github.com/satori/go.uuid | 5b52d72c-82b3-4f8e-beb5-437a974842c |
UUIDv4 from RFC 4112 for comparison |
| https://github.com/google/uuid | c01d7cf6-ec3f-47f0-9556-a5d6e9009a43 |
UUIDv4 |
You can see how the values change over time by refreshing this test page a couple of times.
How to generate unique ids using different libraries:
import (
"fmt"
"log"
"math/rand"
"time"
"github.com/chilts/sid"
guuid "github.com/google/uuid"
"github.com/kjk/betterguid"
"github.com/lithammer/shortuuid"
"github.com/oklog/ulid"
"github.com/rs/xid"
"github.com/satori/go.uuid"
"github.com/segmentio/ksuid"
"github.com/sony/sonyflake"
)
func genShortUUID() {
id := shortuuid.New()
fmt.Printf("github.com/lithammer/shortuuid: %s\n", id)
}
func genUUID() {
id := guuid.New()
fmt.Printf("github.com/google/uuid: %s\n", id.String())
}
func genXid() {
id := xid.New()
fmt.Printf("github.com/rs/xid: %s\n", id.String())
}
func genKsuid() {
id := ksuid.New()
fmt.Printf("github.com/segmentio/ksuid: %s\n", id.String())
}
func genBetterGUID() {
id := betterguid.New()
fmt.Printf("github.com/kjk/betterguid: %s\n", id)
}
func genUlid() {
t := time.Now().UTC()
entropy := rand.New(rand.NewSource(t.UnixNano()))
id := ulid.MustNew(ulid.Timestamp(t), entropy)
fmt.Printf("github.com/oklog/ulid: %s\n", id.String())
}
func genSonyflake() {
flake := sonyflake.NewSonyflake(sonyflake.Settings{})
id, err := flake.NextID()
if err != nil {
log.Fatalf("flake.NextID() failed with %s\n", err)
}
// Note: this is base16, could shorten by encoding as base62 string
fmt.Printf("github.com/sony/sonyflake: %x\n", id)
}
func genSid() {
id := sid.Id()
fmt.Printf("github.com/chilts/sid: %s\n", id)
}
func genUUIDv4() {
id, err := uuid.NewV4()
if err != nil {
log.Fatalf("uuid.NewV4() failed with %s\n", err)
}
fmt.Printf("github.com/satori/go.uuid: %s\n", id)
}Full example: generate-unique-id/main.go
Which one to use?
All of them are good.
I would pick either
rs/xid or segmentio/ksuid.
oklog/ulid allows custom entropy (randomness) source but pays for that with complex API.
sony/sonyflake is the smallest but also the least random. It’s based on Twitter’s design for generating IDs for tweets.
For simplicity the example code serializes
sony/snoflake in base16. It would be even shorter in base62 encoding used by other libraries, but other libraries provide that out-of-the-box and for sony/snoflake I would have to implement it myself.
The last one is UUID v4 from RFC 4112, for comparison.
To learn more:
- https://segment.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-the-uuid/ : the history of ksuid
- https://firebase.googleblog.com/2015/02/the-2120-ways-to-ensure-unique_68.html : inspiration for betterguid design
- http://antoniomo.com/blog/2017/05/21/unique-ids-in-golang-part-1/
- http://antoniomo.com/blog/2017/05/28/unique-ids-in-golang-part-2/
- http://antoniomo.com/blog/2017/06/03/unique-ids-in-golang-part-3/
- https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us/a/2010/announcing-snowflake.html : details of Twitter’s snowflake on which sonyflake is based
Code for this chapter: https://github.com/kjk/go-cookbook/tree/master/generate-unique-id